Briefpoint

California Lemon Law Discovery for Defense Counsel

 In Practice Pointers

California Lemon Law Discovery for Defense Counsel

Legal content overseen by Nathan Walter, Esq., attorney licensed in California (State Bar No. 313299).

California lemon law discovery follows a special procedure only when the manufacturer elected into Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) §§ 871.20–871.30 for the period in which the vehicle was sold and the action falls within the chapter’s scope. In a covered case, represented parties exchange initial disclosures and documents without a discovery request, have the right to take two-hour initial depositions, and stay other discovery until mediation concludes.

Not every Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act action takes this path, and the deadlines run from the answer or other responsive pleading, not from the day a file reaches you.

This guide is for defense counsel and in-house warranty teams new to these California state-court cases.

Which rules govern California lemon law discovery?

The procedure sits in CCP §§ 871.20–871.30, with the central discovery provisions in § 871.26. Public.Law reproduces the statutory text; it is not an official government site. The Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) publishes an official notice for manufacturers.

Match the manufacturer’s election to the vehicle’s sale period

Section 871.29(a)(1) lets a manufacturer elect to be governed by the chapter “with respect to all of the manufacturer’s motor vehicles sold during a period of five consecutive calendar years.” The election is made by written notice to DCA’s Arbitration Certification Program by October 31 of the preceding calendar year. Under § 871.29(a)(2), the manufacturer may not revoke it during that five-year period, but may make a new election covering a later one.

The election attaches to the years in which vehicles were sold. Under § 871.29(b), unless an election covers a given year, §§ 871.20 to 871.28 do not apply to an action described in § 871.20(a) for vehicles sold that year, except as § 871.30 provides.

Section 871.30 adds a transition election for vehicles sold “in the year 2025 and in all prior years,” so transition coverage is not limited to the preceding five years. Under § 871.30(c), without that election the chapter does not apply to such actions, including actions filed between January 1, 2025 and the effective date of the act adding § 871.30.

DCA publishes a list of electing manufacturers (§ 871.29(c)). A name on a list is not the complete test; the question is whether an election covers the year the vehicle was sold. Under § 871.23, a reference to a manufacturer also applies to a distributor or warrantor.

Confirm the action, filing date and representation

Section 871.20(a) applies the chapter to an action against an electing manufacturer “seeking restitution or replacement of a motor vehicle” under the Civil Code provisions it cites, or for civil penalties under Civil Code § 1794(a), where the request is “based on noncompliance with the applicable express warranty.” Section 871.20(b) excludes service contract claims under Civil Code § 1794 and any action seeking remedies other than restitution or replacement.

Section 871.26 applies only to a civil action seeking restitution or replacement under § 871.20 (§ 871.26(a)), only to an action filed on or after January 1, 2025 (§ 871.26(l)), and “does not apply to a party who is not represented by counsel” (§ 871.26(k)). That provision is written by party; this guide does not address a case with both represented and unrepresented parties.

Check applicability in this order:

  1. Identify the defendant (manufacturer, distributor or warrantor) and the vehicle.
  2. Confirm the date the vehicle was sold new and the election, if any, covering that year.
  3. Identify the remedies sought and whether the claim rests on the applicable express warranty.
  4. Check the filing date and whether each party is represented.
  5. Record counsel’s applicability determination and the sources behind it.

Non-election means the chapter’s procedures do not apply to those vehicles. Section 871.28 states that the chapter’s duties are cumulative with duties under other law and do not relieve any party of them. CCP § 2016.090(a)(1), for example, is a separate framework for initial disclosure within 60 days of a demand, subject to its applicability rules and exceptions. How it interacts with the § 871.26 stay is outside this guide.

Calendar the initial exchange and mediation

Use this timeline only after the threshold analysis. The initial-exchange, deposition and mediation periods run from filing the answer or other responsive pleading; ordinary response periods run from service of the requests.

EventStatutory timingAuthority and qualification
Initial disclosure and specified documentsWithin 60 days after filing§ 871.26(b), (f)–(h); no discovery request needed
Schedule mediationWithin 90 days after filing§ 871.26(d)
Initial depositionsRight to conduct within 120 days§ 871.26(c), (i); two hours each; PMQ topics limited
Mediation occursWithin 150 days after filing§ 871.26(d); equal costs; required attendees
Other discoveryStayed until mediation is concluded§ 871.26(e)
Interrogatory responses30 days after service (base period)CCP § 2030.260(a); court may shorten or extend on motion
Request for production (RFP) responses30 days after service (base period)CCP § 2031.260(a); a response period, not a production-completion date
Request for admission (RFA) responses30 days after service (base period)CCP § 2033.250(a); court may shorten or extend on motion

The last three rows are base statutory response periods, not complete date calculations. Service-method extensions, holidays, stipulations and case-specific orders need separate verification and are not covered here. Day 150 is the date by which mediation is to occur; by itself it is not the point at which § 871.26(e) ends the stay.

Build the manufacturer’s initial document packet

Section 871.26(b) requires every party, “without awaiting a discovery request,” to provide an initial disclosure and documents under subdivisions (f), (g) and (h). Subdivision (h) lists seventeen categories for the defendant or manufacturer, cited below by paragraph.

Vehicle and warranty records

  • Copy of or access to a version of the owner’s manual for a vehicle of the same make, model and year (h)(1).
  • Any warranties issued in conjunction with the sale (h)(2), and any warranty extensions or modifications the manufacturer issued on the vehicle (h)(17).
  • Sample brochures published for the vehicle (h)(3).
  • The original invoice to the selling dealer, if any (h)(4).
  • The sales or lease agreement, “if the manufacturer is in possession” (h)(5).
  • Motor vehicle information reports, including build documentation, component information and delivery details (h)(6).
  • The “[e]ntire warranty transaction history” for the vehicle (h)(7).
  • A listing of required field actions applicable to the vehicle (h)(8).

Technical materials and communications

  • Published technical service bulletins (TSBs) for the same make, model and year reasonably related to the nonconformities pertaining to the vehicle (h)(9), and published information service bulletins (ISBs) with the same qualifiers (h)(10).
  • Service manuals reasonably related to the nonconformities (h)(13).
  • Warranty policies and procedure manuals (h)(12).
  • Records relating to communications between the manufacturer or dealership and the owner or lessee, including those related to repair orders or claims involving the vehicle (h)(11).

Only (h)(5) carries a possession qualifier, and the bulletin and service-manual categories are tied to the nonconformities, not to every bulletin for every vehicle.

Records triggered by a pre-suit request

Three items apply only “[i]f a pre-suit restitution or replacement request is made”:

  • All call recordings of pre-suit communications with the consumer available at the time of service of the complaint (h)(14).
  • The manufacturer’s written statement of policies and procedures used to evaluate customer requests for restitution or replacement under “Lemon Law” claims (h)(15).
  • Any nonprivileged, prelitigation evaluation (h)(16).

For intake context, § 871.24 became operative July 1, 2025 (§ 871.24(k)). CCP § 871.24(a) requires a consumer seeking civil penalties to give pre-suit notice at least 30 days before commencing the action. Under § 871.24(h), an action seeking restitution or replacement may be commenced without that notice, but the consumer must possess the vehicle when filing the complaint and may not seek civil penalties by amendment or otherwise.

Record ownership and attorney review

The statute lists documents and does not assign owners. The entries below are an invented illustration of a manual, counsel-controlled checklist, not a legal rule. Whether a particular dealer record is within the manufacturer’s possession is a question for counsel. Bates numbering and a plan to organize discovery documents keep the production traceable.

Warranty transaction history, § 871.26(h)(7)

Proposed owner: warranty operations.

Match: the vehicle’s VIN and the entire history.

Record: extraction date, reviewer and production reference.

Bulletins and service manuals, § 871.26(h)(9), (10), (13)

Proposed owner: technical service publications.

Match: bulletin make, model and year; counsel’s relatedness determination for bulletins and service manuals.

Record: version produced, reviewer and production reference.

Pre-suit communications and evaluation, § 871.26(h)(11), (14)–(16)

Proposed owner: customer relations, with assigned litigation counsel.

Match: vehicle communications under (h)(11), whether or not a pre-suit request was made; for (h)(14)–(16), the pre-suit-request trigger and recordings available when the complaint was served.

Record: privilege review of any evaluation, missing-record status and production reference.

Review the plaintiff’s exchange and prepare the early depositions

Under § 871.26(f), the plaintiff provides documents: the sales or lease agreement, current registration, finance and account information, repair orders (or “the location of where information relating to repair orders may be found”), documents on claimed incidental damages, market-value information in the consumer’s possession, and written pre-suit communications with the manufacturer.

Under § 871.26(g), the plaintiff provides information: mileage as of the disclosure date, primary drivers, whether the plaintiff still has the vehicle and where it is, Armed Forces status, and any interpreter need for a deposition. It also covers business use (whether more than five vehicles are registered to the business), collisions reported to insurance before the nonconformity, aftermarket modifications, presentations not in the repair orders, and pre-suit communications.

The initial depositions are of the plaintiff and of the defendant. For a defendant that is not a natural person, the deponent is “the person who is most qualified to testify on the defendant’s behalf” (§ 871.26(c)(2)), the person most qualified (PMQ). The § 871.26(i) topic limit applies to that organizational deposition, not automatically to every deponent. The topics are:

  • warranties that accompanied the vehicle at purchase or lease;
  • the nature and extent of the entire service history, warranty history and repairs;
  • recalls applicable to the vehicle;
  • “a reasonable number” of TSBs or ISBs reasonably related to the nonconformities;
  • relevant diagnostic and repair procedures consulted and followed;
  • relevant communications with the plaintiff and with any dealership or other third parties;
  • if a pre-suit request was made, why the defendant did not replace the vehicle or provide restitution, any nonprivileged evaluation, and the manufacturer’s policies and procedures on such requests from the date of the consumer’s notice to the present, and any changes.

Mediation, the discovery stay and noncompliance

Under § 871.26(d), all parties schedule mediation within 90 days after the answer or other responsive pleading, for a mediation within 150 days, with a court-appointed or private mediator. Costs “shall be distributed equally, but costs may be recoverable by the plaintiff as part of a settlement or judgment” (§ 871.26(d)(1)). The plaintiff and “a person with settlement authority for the manufacturer” attend in person or by remote means (§ 871.26(d)(2)).

Section 871.26(e) provides that, except as provided in subdivisions (b) and (c), “all other discovery shall be stayed until mediation is concluded.” Ordinary interrogatories, requests for production, requests for admission and broader depositions are not listed as additional exceptions.

Section 871.26(j) applies “[u]nless the party failing to comply with this section shows good cause.” A court “shall impose” these sanctions:

  • $2,500 against the defense attorney (or $1,500 against the plaintiff’s attorney), paid within 15 business days, for failure to comply with the document production requirements of subdivision (b) (§ 871.26(j)(1)), and the same amounts for failure to comply with the deposition provisions of subdivision (c) (§ 871.26(j)(2));
  • for a plaintiff’s repeated noncompliance with subdivision (b), (c) or (d), dismissal without prejudice and the plaintiff’s attorney responsible for costs awarded to the manufacturer (§ 871.26(j)(3)); and
  • for a manufacturer’s or defendant’s repeated noncompliance with subdivision (b), (c) or (d), evidentiary sanctions precluding evidence at trial on whether the vehicle had a nonconformity that substantially impaired its use, value or safety, or whether it was repaired to match the written warranty after a reasonable number of opportunities (§ 871.26(j)(4)).

The monetary amounts are stated against counsel, not the manufacturer. Section 871.26(j)(5) provides that the court “may, in its discretion, require” a sanctioned attorney to report the sanction in writing to the State Bar of California within 30 days of its imposition.

Settlement performance is governed elsewhere. Under § 871.27(g)(2), the defendant must complete an agreed restitution or replacement within 30 days of receiving a signed release from the buyer or lessee’s counsel, and failure “shall result in a mandatory penalty of fifty dollars ($50) per day” unless the parties stipulate otherwise. The penalty runs until settlement is completed. The consumer must comply in good faith with reasonable documentation requests; if failure to do so delays restitution or replacement, the manufacturer is not subject to the daily penalty. It is not a sanction for late initial documents.

Resume ordinary written discovery with case-specific responses

If the case is not resolved at the conclusion of mediation, § 871.26(e) provides that “standard discovery procedures” under Title 4 of Part 4 of the CCP (commencing with § 2016.010) apply, including an additional deposition of the plaintiff and the defendant and, for a non-natural-person defendant, the PMQ.

For responding to interrogatories in California, the base response period is 30 days after service (CCP § 2030.260(a)). Under CCP § 2030.030, no party may, as a matter of right, propound to any other party more than 35 specially prepared interrogatories; if the first set does not exhaust the limit, the balance may be propounded in later sets, except as § 2030.070 provides. Official form interrogatories are counted separately, and a responding party need only answer the first 35 specially prepared interrogatories if it objects to the balance on the ground that the limit was exceeded, unless a § 2030.050 declaration has been made (§ 2030.030(c)).

Under CCP § 2030.250, the responding party signs interrogatory responses under oath unless they contain only objections, and a corporation acts through an officer or agent. If that signer is an attorney acting in that capacity, the party waives lawyer-client privilege and work-product protection in later discovery from that attorney about the identity of the sources of the information. The attorney signs any response that contains an objection.

For requests for production, CCP § 2031.240(a) requires a statement of compliance or a representation of inability to comply for the remainder of any item that is only partly objectionable. Section 2031.240(b)(1) also requires identifying with particularity the items to which an objection is made. An objection must set forth “the extent of, and the specific ground for,” the objection, identify any privilege invoked and expressly assert work-product protection if that is a ground for the objection (§ 2031.240(b)(2)). Where privilege or work product is claimed, the response must give “sufficient factual information for other parties to evaluate the merits of that claim, including, if necessary, a privilege log” (§ 2031.240(c)(1)). The base response period is 30 days after service (CCP § 2031.260(a)).

Prepare defense discovery responses with Briefpoint

Briefpoint supports the written discovery that follows the initial exchange. Deciding whether the chapter applies and assembling the § 871.26 initial exchange remain counsel’s manual work.

Once interrogatories, RFPs and RFAs arrive, Briefpoint for defense firms drafts responses and objections that attorneys review and edit in Word. Discovery Playbooks entries can be scoped to a client, jurisdiction and case type, so the approved objections and response appear under each matching request before drafting. Attorneys apply them with Use Objections, Use Response, or Use and rewrite, which rewrites a prior response with the new case’s facts. Counsel decide what is served. Updating an entry once means every attorney drafting afterward sees the new version.

For requests for production, Autodoc finds responsive documents, adds page-level Bates citations and builds a Bates-numbered production package. See also discovery response software.

Book a demo to explore Briefpoint for your team’s written discovery workflow.

Watch the Briefpoint demo:

FAQs About California Lemon Law Discovery

Does AB 1755 apply to every California lemon law case?

No. CCP § 871.20(a) applies the chapter to actions against a manufacturer that elected under § 871.29, and § 871.29(b) excludes vehicles sold in a year no election covers, except as § 871.30 provides. Section 871.26 also reaches only qualifying restitution or replacement actions filed on or after January 1, 2025, and not parties without counsel.

Do manufacturers need a discovery request before producing initial documents?

No, in a covered case. Section 871.26(b) requires all parties, “without awaiting a discovery request,” to provide an initial disclosure and documents under subdivisions (f), (g) and (h) within 60 days after the answer or other responsive pleading is filed. Subdivision (h) lists the manufacturer’s documents; three items apply only if a pre-suit restitution or replacement request was made.

Can the parties take depositions before lemon law mediation?

Yes, but only the initial depositions that § 871.26(c) defines. All parties have the right to conduct them within 120 days after the answer or other responsive pleading, each not exceeding two hours, of the plaintiff and the defendant or, for an organization, its PMQ. The PMQ deposition is limited to the topics in § 871.26(i). Other discovery is stayed under § 871.26(e).

Does the discovery stay end automatically after 150 days?

No. Section 871.26(d) calls for mediation to occur within 150 days after the answer or other responsive pleading, but § 871.26(e) stays all other discovery “until mediation is concluded.” The statutory wording ties the stay to the conclusion of mediation, not to an elapsed number of days.

What happens if mediation does not resolve the case?

Under § 871.26(e), standard discovery procedures in Title 4 of Part 4 of the CCP (commencing with § 2016.010) apply, including an additional deposition of the plaintiff and the defendant and, for a non-natural-person defendant, the PMQ. Written discovery under CCP §§ 2030, 2031 and 2033 then follows its base response periods of 30 days after service, unless the court has shortened or extended the time.

The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only. Information on this website may not constitute the most up-to-date legal or other information. This website contains links to other third-party websites. Such links are only for the convenience of the reader, user or browser. Readers of this website should contact their attorney to obtain advice with respect to any particular legal matter. No reader, user, or browser of this site should act or refrain from acting on the basis of information on this site without first seeking legal advice from counsel in the relevant jurisdiction. Only your individual attorney can provide assurances that the information contained herein – and your interpretation of it – is applicable or appropriate to your particular situation. Use of, and access to, this website or any of the links or resources contained within the site do not create an attorney-client relationship between the reader, user, or browser and website authors, contributors, contributing law firms, or committee members and their respective employers.

Recent Posts

Leave a Comment