Briefpoint

What Is New Jersey Multicounty Litigation?

 In Practice Pointers

What Is New Jersey Multicounty Litigation?

Legal content overseen by Nathan Walter, Esq., attorney licensed in California (State Bar No. 313299).

New Jersey multicounty litigation, or MCL, is centralized court management of related cases designated by the New Jersey Supreme Court. For product-related litigation, the New Jersey Judiciary describes cases that share factual and legal issues, with the designated MCL court managing conferences, discovery scheduling and preparation of cases for trial.

This guide is for defense counsel, including firms defending related product-liability cases.

It explains New Jersey state-court practice, with a short federal comparison: where an MCL is managed, what the initial case management order (CMO) covers and where discovery dates come from. For the drafting side, see Briefpoint and its page on written discovery for defense firms.

What is New Jersey multicounty litigation?

New Jersey multicounty litigation is the centralized management of related cases that the New Jersey Supreme Court designates as an MCL. In the product-related cases the Judiciary describes, a large number of personal injury cases are associated with a single product and share common factual and legal issues, and an assigned judge coordinates them through discovery and trial preparation (NJ Judiciary, Multicounty Litigation).

The Judiciary’s introduction adds that the value of each claim depends on the value of all the other claims. This article uses that product-case description as its scope. It is not an eligibility test, and the guide does not set out designation criteria. An MCL exists because the Supreme Court designated it by order, so related claims are not treated here as automatically qualifying.

A firm’s own coordination of separate matters is not an MCL. A defense team that applies one process across related claims no court has centralized is running an internal operating model, the subject of the guide to managing discovery across repeated claims. An MCL is a court-managed proceeding, and its working arrangements come from court orders.

Which court handles a New Jersey MCL?

Each New Jersey MCL is handled in one of three counties: Bergen, Middlesex or Atlantic. The Supreme Court’s order that designates an MCL also assigns it to one of those counties, and the Judiciary says future cases in that designated litigation are to be filed there as well (NJ Judiciary, “Understanding the MCL Process”).

The designation order and the CMO do different jobs. The Supreme Court’s designation order names the litigation as an MCL and assigns its county. The judge assigned to oversee the MCL then prepares the initial case management order, which the next section covers. A defense team may keep the designation order and the latest CMO together in the matter’s working file (an editorial workflow suggestion, not a legal requirement).

The county statement applies to cases within the designated litigation. The guide does not say that a company’s unrelated cases move to the MCL county, and it describes no application deadline, transfer deadline or automatic stay, so this article states none.

What does the initial MCL case management order cover?

The judge assigned to a New Jersey MCL prepares an initial case management order. The Judiciary says the order includes the date of the first case management conference, direction to counsel on issues to discuss before that conference, instructions on notices on the Judiciary’s MCL web page and on contact with the court, obligations on preservation of records and e-discovery, and a process for appointing lead and liaison counsel (NJ Judiciary, “Understanding the MCL Process”).

The date of the first conference comes from the order itself. The guide does not give a standard number of days between designation and that conference.

The guide names preservation of records and e-discovery as a subject of the order but does not describe what those obligations require. What they require in a particular MCL is a question for that MCL’s order.

A defense team that receives a new or amended CMO may track these fields in the matter file. They are suggested working-file fields, not court-required form fields or Briefpoint features:

  • Order and version: which order it is and whether it is the latest.
  • Affected matter: the cases in the team’s caseload that the order covers.
  • Scheduled event: the conference or discovery date the order states.
  • Task owner: the person responsible for that event.
  • Client information needed: the facts or documents the client must supply for it.
  • Counsel review: the attorney who confirms what the order requires.

Objection grounds for individual requests are a separate subject, covered in the guide to New Jersey discovery objections. That guide is a related article, not primary authority.

How are discovery dates set in a New Jersey MCL?

The Judiciary says an MCL court holds case management conferences at which it asks about ongoing discovery issues, sets a schedule for motion practice on disputes, and sets a schedule to complete written discovery, depositions and service of general expert reports. Conferences are usually scheduled every four to six weeks. That interval describes typical practice; it is not a response deadline or a discovery cutoff (NJ Judiciary, “Understanding the MCL Process”).

Before each conference, the Judiciary says, the court normally requires counsel to confer and submit a proposed joint agenda. Keep three kinds of timing separate:

  • A conference interval is how often the court meets with counsel. The guide gives four to six weeks as the usual pattern.
  • A date stated in an order is a schedule the court sets for a particular litigation, such as the first conference date in the initial CMO.
  • A device-specific response period is the time to answer a particular interrogatory, request for production or request for admission. The guide gives no MCL-wide response period, so that question is separate from the conference calendar. For interrogatory mechanics in New Jersey, see New Jersey interrogatory answers and deadlines.

Quick Reference: New Jersey Multicounty Litigation Discovery Orientation

Who designates the MCL and its county?

The New Jersey Supreme Court, by order.

Authority: NJ Judiciary guide, process section, opening paragraph

Which counties does the Judiciary identify?

Bergen, Middlesex and Atlantic.

Authority: NJ Judiciary guide, same paragraph

Where is the first conference date stated?

In the initial case management order.

Authority: NJ Judiciary guide, initial-order list

How often are conferences usually held?

Every four to six weeks; typical practice, not a universal deadline.

Authority: NJ Judiciary guide, conference paragraph

Where do discovery scheduling details come from?

The litigation’s court-directed schedule, not the MCL label.

Authority: NJ Judiciary guide, conference scheduling list

Does the initial order address preservation?

The Judiciary lists preservation of records and e-discovery among its subjects.

Authority: NJ Judiciary guide, initial-order list

How is New Jersey MCL different from federal MDL?

New Jersey MCL is a state-court process managed in a county designated by the New Jersey Supreme Court (NJ Judiciary). Federal multidistrict litigation (MDL) is the transfer of related federal civil actions pending in different districts for coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings, decided by the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation under 28 U.S.C. § 1407(a). The two are distinct proceedings with their own orders and schedules, although the Judiciary says MCL judges work with federal courts handling corresponding litigation and coordinate discovery with related litigation in other state courts (NJ Judiciary).

Section 1407(a) covers civil actions involving one or more common questions of fact that are pending in different districts. The panel makes the transfer on its determination that it will be for the convenience of parties and witnesses and will promote the just and efficient conduct of the actions (28 U.S.C. § 1407(a)).

The Panel’s own description adds that it also selects the judge or judges and the court assigned to conduct those proceedings, and that centralization aims to avoid duplication of discovery, prevent inconsistent pretrial rulings and conserve the resources of the parties, their counsel and the judiciary.

Federal written-discovery practice is outside this comparison. For a federal starting point, not a New Jersey one, see the federal discovery-response background.

How can Briefpoint help with written discovery in an MCL?

Briefpoint drafts responses and objections to interrogatories, requests for production and requests for admission, with output editable in Microsoft Word. Autodoc document matching and Bates citations finds responsive documents, adds page-level Bates citations and builds a Bates-numbered production package. Attorneys keep final review, including review against the orders and facts of the particular matter.

Client Bridge fact and document collection sends clients plain-language questions through a secure link so they can answer and upload documents for attorney review, with Spanish client translations. Briefpoint supports all 50 states and 98 federal courts, and also offers Discovery Playbooks. This describes drafting, client fact collection and production support. Counsel still check drafts against the initial CMO and later orders discussed above. Briefpoint for corporate defense teams has more on the defense use case.

Book a demo to explore Briefpoint for your defense team’s written discovery.

Watch the Briefpoint video:

What else should defense teams know about New Jersey multicounty litigation?

The Judiciary says the goal of an MCL is to select a pool of cases to be made ready for trial, with representative bellwether trials then helping resolve the remaining cases. It also says no two MCLs are the same, each has its own variables, and there is no way to predict how long any MCL will last (NJ Judiciary, “Understanding the MCL Process”).

The Judiciary adds that the judge assigned to the MCL typically oversees the trial of the cases. Because each MCL has its own orders, a defense team may check the designation order, the initial CMO and the latest conference schedule for the litigation at hand before relying on any general description, including this one.

What does MCL stand for in New Jersey courts?

MCL stands for multicounty litigation. In the Judiciary’s description, the Supreme Court’s designation order assigns the litigation to one of three counties, and the judge assigned to oversee it prepares an initial case management order. In the product-related litigation discussed here, the cases share factual and legal issues. Source: NJ Judiciary.

Are New Jersey MCL conferences always held every four weeks?

No. The Judiciary says MCL conferences are usually scheduled every four to six weeks, which describes a typical interval rather than a fixed requirement for every case. The initial case management order supplies the first conference date. Later conference dates and discovery events belong to the particular litigation’s schedule. Source: NJ Judiciary.

Is there one discovery deadline for every New Jersey MCL?

The Judiciary’s MCL guide does not give one discovery deadline for every proceeding. It describes the court setting, at case management conferences, schedules for motion practice on disputes and for completing written discovery, depositions and service of general expert reports. A conference interval is not a response period, and one order’s date cannot be assumed to apply to a different MCL. Source: NJ Judiciary.

What is a bellwether trial in a New Jersey MCL?

A bellwether trial is a trial of representative plaintiffs’ cases, used to help evaluate the broader litigation. The Judiciary says the court selects representative plaintiffs from a pool of trial-ready cases, and that the trials establish trends or common rulings that can predict a potential outcome for some or all remaining cases. The guide states no timetable for resolution. Source: NJ Judiciary.

Can multiple plaintiffs present their cases in one New Jersey MCL trial?

The Judiciary says some MCL courts have allowed multiple plaintiffs to present their cases in one trial. First, the court must determine that a multi-plaintiff trial can be accomplished without undue prejudice to the defendants. The guide does not describe MCL designation itself as requiring every claim to be tried together. Source: NJ Judiciary.

The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only. Information on this website may not constitute the most up-to-date legal or other information. This website contains links to other third-party websites. Such links are only for the convenience of the reader, user or browser. Readers of this website should contact their attorney to obtain advice with respect to any particular legal matter. No reader, user, or browser of this site should act or refrain from acting on the basis of information on this site without first seeking legal advice from counsel in the relevant jurisdiction. Only your individual attorney can provide assurances that the information contained herein – and your interpretation of it – is applicable or appropriate to your particular situation. Use of, and access to, this website or any of the links or resources contained within the site do not create an attorney-client relationship between the reader, user, or browser and website authors, contributors, contributing law firms, or committee members and their respective employers.

Recent Posts

Leave a Comment