Briefpoint

Inaccessible ESI Discovery: Can You Refuse Production?

 In Practice Pointers

Inaccessible ESI Discovery: Can You Refuse Production?

Legal content overseen by Nathan Walter, Esq., attorney licensed in California (State Bar No. 313299).

In federal inaccessible ESI discovery, Rule 26(b)(2)(B) says a party need not provide discovery from sources it identifies as not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost.

If challenged on a motion to compel or for a protective order, the responding party must prove that inaccessibility; the court may still order discovery if the requesting party shows good cause, considering Rule 26(b)(2)(C).

An accessibility objection does not resolve preservation questions under Rule 37(e) or replace the written response to a request for production (RFP) required by Rule 34(b)(2)(A)–(C).

Below: who carries each burden, what a court may order anyway, and what an in-house team can document for litigation counsel.

What does inaccessible ESI discovery mean under Rule 26?

Inaccessible ESI discovery concerns electronically stored information (ESI) from sources identified as not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(2)(B). The rule turns on the source and the burden or cost of obtaining the information, not a blanket label applied to every electronic record.

“Not reasonably accessible” does not mean impossible to retrieve. Rule 26(b)(2)(B) states no dollar amount, data volume or age that makes a source inaccessible, so a source’s age, backup status or size does not by itself establish inaccessibility. For a decommissioned legacy archive, the responding party needs to explain what retrieval involves and why that is an undue burden or cost.

Rule 26(b)(1) separately defines the scope of discovery as any nonprivileged matter relevant to a party’s claim or defense and proportional to the needs of the case, considering factors that include whether the burden or expense of the proposed discovery outweighs its likely benefit. Rule 26(b)(2)(B) is a distinct provision from that scope definition.

Inaccessible ESI Discovery Quick Reference

QuestionFederal rule answerAuthority
What source can a party identify?One not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or costRule 26(b)(2)(B)
Who proves inaccessibility on a motion to compel or for a protective order?The party from whom discovery is soughtRule 26(b)(2)(B)
Can discovery still be ordered?Yes, if the requesting party shows good cause; the court may set conditionsRule 26(b)(2)(B)–(C)
Is a written response to the RFP still required?Yes; state grounds with specificity and whether anything is withheldRule 34(b)(2)(A)–(C)
Does the objection resolve preservation?No; loss of ESI is addressed separatelyRule 37(e)

Who has to prove that ESI is not reasonably accessible?

Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(2)(B), on a motion to compel discovery or for a protective order, the responding party must show that the information is not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost. If that showing is made, the requesting party bears the next showing: good cause for discovery from those sources.

Identify the source

The rule refers to “sources that the party identifies as not reasonably accessible.” In practice, that points counsel toward naming the specific system, repository or storage medium at issue, with the relevant date range, rather than describing a whole category of records as burdensome.

Support the burden or cost explanation

The rule does not list the kinds of evidence that make the showing, so an IT description or a vendor estimate is an input to the showing, not a substitute for it.

A motion to compel under Rule 37(a)(1) and a motion for a protective order under Rule 26(c)(1) must each include a certification of good-faith conferral or an attempt to confer.

Can a judge order production of inaccessible ESI anyway?

Yes. Even after the responding party establishes inaccessibility, Rule 26(b)(2)(B) permits discovery for good cause, subject to Rule 26(b)(2)(C), and allows the court to specify conditions. Rule 26(c)(1)(B) separately permits a protective order specifying terms, including allocation of expenses, for good cause.

Rule 26(b)(2)(C) says the court must limit discovery if it determines any of these:

  • the discovery is unreasonably cumulative or duplicative, or can be obtained from some other source that is more convenient, less burdensome or less expensive;
  • the requesting party has had ample opportunity to obtain the information by discovery in the action; or
  • the proposed discovery is outside the scope permitted by Rule 26(b)(1).

A protective order under Rule 26(c)(1) can also forbid the discovery, prescribe a different discovery method than the one the requesting party chose, or limit its scope to certain matters. If the motion is wholly or partly denied, Rule 26(c)(2) lets the court order discovery on just terms.

Cost shifting is possible under Rule 26(c)(1)(B), not automatic. Nothing in the cited rule text creates a presumption that the requesting party pays, or prescribes a phased search or limited restoration; parties may propose those, and the court decides whether to order any conditions.

What should an in-house team document before objecting to inaccessible ESI?

An in-house team can give litigation counsel a source-specific record of where the information is stored, what retrieval requires, and the basis for any burden or cost estimate. This is a practical way to support the Rule 26(b)(2)(B) showing, not a checklist prescribed by the rule or a guarantee that an objection will succeed.

1. Identify the systems and dates

List each system that may hold responsive information, the custodian or owner, and the period the request covers.

2. Ask knowledgeable IT staff what retrieval involves

Ask the people who run the system what restoring or searching it requires in concrete steps. Record who gave each answer and when.

3. Separate supported estimates from unknowns

Record the author, date and assumptions behind any time or cost estimate, and list the questions still unanswered. Budget context for those figures is in understanding eDiscovery costs.

4. Identify accessible alternatives

Note whether the same information sits in an easier-to-search source. Rule 26(b)(2)(C)(i) addresses discovery obtainable from a more convenient, less burdensome or less expensive source; whether an alternative resolves the dispute is for counsel and, if disputed, the court.

5. Give counsel the facts for the written response

A practical fact sheet can include these fields:

  • Source and custodian: the system name and who maintains it.
  • Relevant period: the dates the source covers.
  • Technical obstacle: why retrieval is difficult.
  • Restoration steps: what retrieval would involve.
  • Estimate: author, date and assumptions.
  • Accessible duplicates: where the same information may also reside.
  • Open questions: what remains unknown.

How the written response uses those facts

Rule 34(b)(2)(B) requires, for each item or category, either a statement that inspection will be permitted as requested or specific grounds for objecting, including the reasons. Rule 34(b)(2)(C) requires an objection to state whether any responsive materials are being withheld on the basis of that objection, and an objection to part of a request must specify the part and permit inspection of the rest. A generic “unduly burdensome” objection does not meet that text.

Counsel can draw on the fact sheet when preparing written discovery responses; organizing discovery documents covers the records work behind it.

The response is due in writing within 30 days after service, or 30 days after the parties’ first Rule 26(f) conference if the request was delivered under Rule 26(d)(2); Rule 34(b)(2)(A) allows a shorter or longer time by Rule 29 stipulation or court order.

Example: a retired payroll archive

This example is invented for illustration. In an employment dispute, a request for production seeks payroll records for a defined period.

A records manager identifies a retired payroll archive, describes the restoration steps it would require, and reports which months a searchable current export covers. Counsel compares both sources against the requested dates; neither is treated as exempt at that stage.

Does an inaccessible-ESI objection let us delete the source?

No automatic deletion permission follows from Rule 26(b)(2)(B): that provision addresses providing discovery from a source, not whether evidence may be destroyed. Rule 37(e) separately addresses ESI that should have been preserved, was lost for failure to take reasonable steps, and cannot be restored or replaced through additional discovery.

When those conditions are met, Rule 37(e) sets two tiers. On a finding of prejudice to another party, the court may order measures no greater than necessary to cure the prejudice. Only on a finding that the party acted with the intent to deprive another party of the information’s use in the litigation may the court presume the lost information was unfavorable, instruct the jury that it may or must presume so, or dismiss the action or enter a default judgment.

Whether a particular source must be preserved is a case-specific question for litigation counsel.

Is inaccessible ESI the same as an objection to producing native files?

No. Rule 26(b)(2)(B) concerns whether information from a source is reasonably accessible because of burden or cost, while Rule 34(b)(2)(D) governs an objection to the requested production form. When no form is specified, Rule 34(b)(2)(E)(ii) generally requires a form in which the ESI is ordinarily maintained or a reasonably usable form, unless otherwise stipulated or ordered.

If the response objects to the requested form, or no form was specified, Rule 34(b)(2)(D) requires the responding party to state the form or forms it intends to use. A disagreement about form is therefore a separate objection from a Rule 26(b)(2)(B) source objection. Agreeing on forms in advance is covered in creating an ESI protocol.

How can Briefpoint support the written-response workflow?

Briefpoint drafts responses and objections to requests for production, interrogatories and requests for admission, with output editable in Microsoft Word and attorneys keeping final review. Client Bridge sends clients plain-language questions through a secure link so they can answer and upload documents for attorney review. Autodoc finds responsive documents, adds page-level Bates citations (references using document page identifiers) and builds a Bates-numbered production package once documents are available.

Together they move documented client facts and documents into an attorney-reviewed written response.

Those features sit in Briefpoint’s discovery drafting platform, which also supports discovery workflows for in-house teams. Attorneys and technical personnel determine the retrieval facts and the legal position, including whether a source is not reasonably accessible under Rule 26(b)(2)(B). Counsel decides which objections to assert and how to word them.

Book a demo to see how Briefpoint supports attorney-reviewed discovery drafting.

Watch the Briefpoint demo:

FAQs About Inaccessible ESI Discovery

Federal inaccessible ESI discovery turns on the source-specific rule in Rule 26(b)(2)(B), not a universal exception for old or expensive data. The answers below distinguish that rule from preservation, cost allocation and written-response requirements.

Are backup tapes automatically exempt from discovery?

No. Federal Rule 26(b)(2)(B) does not create a blanket exemption for backup tapes or old systems. It addresses sources identified as not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost. On a motion to compel or for a protective order, the responding party must support that showing, and a requesting party can still establish good cause for discovery.

Who pays if a court orders inaccessible ESI to be produced?

The cited rules do not automatically make the requesting party pay. Rule 26(b)(2)(B) permits the court to specify conditions for the discovery, and Rule 26(c)(1)(B) permits terms, including allocation of expenses, in a protective order for good cause. Allocation therefore depends on the applicable order or agreement, not on the mere use of an accessibility objection.

Can we ignore an RFP while IT investigates retrieval costs?

No. An IT investigation does not replace the written response required by Federal Rule 34(b)(2)(A), which generally comes due 30 days after service, subject to a stipulated or court-ordered change and a special rule for early-delivered requests. Counsel needs the available technical facts to state any objection with the specificity Rule 34(b)(2)(B) requires.

Does an inaccessible-ESI objection mean we can stop preserving it?

No automatic preservation exemption follows from the objection. Rule 26(b)(2)(B) concerns providing discovery from identified sources; Rule 37(e) separately addresses qualifying losses of ESI that should have been preserved. Whether particular information must be preserved is a case-specific legal question, and retrieval cost alone is not permission to delete a source.

Can the court require discovery even after we prove inaccessibility?

Yes. Federal Rule 26(b)(2)(B) permits the court to order discovery if the requesting party shows good cause, considering Rule 26(b)(2)(C). Those limits cover unreasonable duplication, more convenient or less burdensome alternative sources, ample prior opportunity to obtain the information, and discovery outside the scope of Rule 26(b)(1). The court may also specify conditions for the discovery.

The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only. Information on this website may not constitute the most up-to-date legal or other information. This website contains links to other third-party websites. Such links are only for the convenience of the reader, user or browser. Readers of this website should contact their attorney to obtain advice with respect to any particular legal matter. No reader, user, or browser of this site should act or refrain from acting on the basis of information on this site without first seeking legal advice from counsel in the relevant jurisdiction. Only your individual attorney can provide assurances that the information contained herein – and your interpretation of it – is applicable or appropriate to your particular situation. Use of, and access to, this website or any of the links or resources contained within the site do not create an attorney-client relationship between the reader, user, or browser and website authors, contributors, contributing law firms, or committee members and their respective employers.

Recent Posts

Leave a Comment