Rule 35 Examiner Report: What Does Requesting It Waive?
Rule 35 Examiner Report: What Does Requesting It Waive?
Legal content overseen by Nathan Walter, Esq., attorney licensed in California (State Bar No. 313299).
In federal civil litigation, the party who moved for a physical or mental examination must deliver the examiner’s report, with like reports of earlier examinations of the same condition, when the examined party or person asks for it (FRCP 35(b)(1)).
A Rule 35 examiner report request has a consequence: under Rule 35(b)(4), requesting and obtaining the report, or deposing the examiner, waives the examined party’s privilege concerning testimony about all examinations of the same condition.
The sections below cover who may request the report, what it must contain, the reciprocal request, agreed examinations, the missing-report remedy and the waiver language, whether counsel work by hand or with discovery software for plaintiff firms.
Who can request a Rule 35 examiner report?
Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35(b)(1), the party against whom an examination order was issued, or the person examined, may request the examiner’s report. The party who moved for the examination must then deliver a copy, together with like reports of all earlier examinations of the same condition.
The rule’s text is: “The party who moved for the examination must, on request, deliver to the requester a copy of the examiner’s report, together with like reports of all earlier examinations of the same condition. The request may be made by the party against whom the examination order was issued or by the person examined.” When a defendant moves to examine a plaintiff, the plaintiff is both the party against whom the order issued and the person examined. The rule’s labels describe roles, so they need not match plaintiff and defendant in every case.
The examination itself is ordered under Rule 35(a). Rule 35(a)(1) allows the court where the action is pending to order a party “whose mental or physical condition—including blood group—is in controversy” to submit to an examination by a suitably licensed or certified examiner, and Rule 35(a)(2)(A) requires “a motion for good cause” with “notice to all parties and the person to be examined.” The examination is one of the types of legal discovery; the report exchange in Rule 35(b) is separate from the order that authorizes it.
What must the examiner’s report contain?
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35(b)(2) requires a written report that sets out the examiner’s findings in detail, including diagnoses, conclusions and the results of any tests. The report delivered under Rule 35(b)(1) comes with like reports of earlier examinations of the same condition, so the exchange can include more than one document.
The rule says: “The examiner’s report must be in writing and must set out in detail the examiner’s findings, including diagnoses, conclusions, and the results of any tests.” An examiner’s report, in the rule’s sense, is that written findings report, not the examiner’s entire file or the whole medical record.
A review checklist that tracks the rule text:
- Written report: a writing was delivered, not only oral findings.
- Detailed findings: the findings are set out in detail.
- Diagnoses and conclusions: both appear.
- Test results: the results of any tests are included.
- Earlier reports: like reports of earlier examinations of the same condition arrived with it.
The checklist does not assess medical correctness. Rule 35(b)(2) refers to “the results of any tests”; the subsection’s text does not by itself say that raw test protocols, proprietary instruments or an examiner’s complete file must be delivered.
What does requesting and obtaining the report waive?
Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35(b)(4), requesting and obtaining the examiner’s report, or deposing the examiner, waives any privilege the party examined may have concerning testimony about all examinations of the same condition. The waiver applies in the action and in any other action involving the same controversy. The rule’s text does not describe a blanket waiver of every medical record or of unrelated conditions.
The full subsection reads: “By requesting and obtaining the examiner’s report, or by deposing the examiner, the party examined waives any privilege it may have—in that action or any other action involving the same controversy—concerning testimony about all examinations of the same condition.”
The text names two separate triggers:
- Requesting and obtaining the report. The words are conjunctive. The subsection says “requesting and obtaining,” and a summary that says only “requesting” drops half the trigger.
- Deposing the examiner. This path operates independently of the report.
Rule 35(b)(4) does not define “same condition,” and this article does not offer a test for how broadly it reaches. Whether a particular privilege is affected, and how Rule 35(b)(4) interacts with any other waiver doctrine, depends on the case, the jurisdiction and the facts. Counsel should assess those questions separately before sending a request.
What reports can the moving party request in return?
After delivering the reports, the party who moved for the examination may request, and is entitled to receive, like reports of all earlier or later examinations of the same condition from the party against whom the order was issued, under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35(b)(3). A party with custody or control of the person examined need not deliver those reports if it shows that it could not obtain them.
The sequence in the text is request, delivery, then reciprocal request. The moving party’s own delivery under Rule 35(b)(1) comes first, and the right to request in return arises “after delivering the reports.” Rule 35(b)(1) covers earlier same-condition reports; Rule 35(b)(3) allows the moving party to request earlier or later ones in return.
The subsection’s second sentence is: “But those reports need not be delivered by the party with custody or control of the person examined if the party shows that it could not obtain them.” The exception depends on a showing that the reports could not be obtained. It does not excuse a party that simply says a report is unavailable.
Is there a 30-day deadline to deliver the report?
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35(b) does not state a fixed number of days for delivering the examiner’s report. The 30-day written-response period in Rule 34(b)(2)(A) belongs to Rule 34 requests, with its own qualifications, and should not be copied onto a standalone Rule 35(b) request.
Rule 34(b)(2)(A) says the responding party “must respond in writing within 30 days after being served or — if the request was delivered under Rule 26(d)(2) — within 30 days after the parties’ first Rule 26(f) conference,” and that “[a] shorter or longer time may be stipulated to under Rule 29 or be ordered by the court.” That clock governs responses to requests for production. The text of Rule 35(b)(1) says the moving party must deliver the report “on request” and names no period.
A missing day count does not mean unlimited time: the examination order, the parties’ agreement or the case schedule may set a date. Counsel should identify the governing order, agreement and procedural route for the case at hand and not assume a universal deadline.
For federal examination-report exchanges, these are the Rule 35(b) distinctions to keep separate:
- Initial delivery, Rule 35(b)(1): on request, the report plus like reports of earlier examinations of the same condition.
- Contents, Rule 35(b)(2): written, detailed findings, including diagnoses, conclusions and the results of any tests.
- Reciprocal request, Rule 35(b)(3): after delivery, the moving party may request earlier or later same-condition reports; a party with custody or control of the person examined is excused if it shows it could not obtain them.
- Waiver trigger, Rule 35(b)(4): requesting and obtaining the report, or deposing the examiner.
- Waiver scope, Rule 35(b)(4): any privilege the party examined may have concerning testimony about all examinations of the same condition, in that action or any other action involving the same controversy.
- Missing report, Rule 35(b)(5): the court on motion may order delivery on just terms and, if the report is not provided, may exclude the examiner’s testimony at trial.
- Agreed examination, Rule 35(b)(6): subdivision (b) applies unless the agreement states otherwise.
- Fixed day count: none stated in Rule 35(b); Rule 34’s 30-day response period is a separate clock.
Does Rule 35(b) apply to an agreed examination?
Yes. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35(b)(6) applies the report provisions to an examination made by the parties’ agreement unless the agreement states otherwise. The same subsection says Rule 35(b) does not preclude obtaining an examiner’s report or deposing an examiner under other rules.
Not every examination requires a court order. Rule 35(a) provides for an order on motion; Rule 35(b)(6) says “[t]his subdivision (b) applies also to an examination made by the parties’ agreement, unless the agreement states otherwise.” An agreement may change the application of subdivision (b); that exception does not itself resolve disclosure duties under other rules or establish that another procedural route avoids privilege consequences.
This hypothetical is invented for illustration. A plaintiff undergoes an agreed examination concerning a knee condition, and the agreement is silent on Rule 35(b). Counsel evaluating a report request would check the agreement, whether earlier same-condition reports came with the report, the moving party’s reciprocal right after delivery and the exact waiver language in Rule 35(b)(4). Nothing in the rule’s text makes every unrelated medical condition discoverable because of that request.
Rule 35 report versus Rule 26 expert report
Rule 35(b)(2) and Rule 26(a)(2)(B) impose different report requirements. Rule 26(a)(2)(B) provides that, “[u]nless otherwise stipulated or ordered by the court,” an expert disclosure “must be accompanied by a written report—prepared and signed by the witness—if the witness is one retained or specially employed to provide expert testimony in the case or one whose duties as the party’s employee regularly involve giving expert testimony.” That requirement is conditional on the witness and the case. The two rules have separate triggers and required contents; satisfying one set of requirements does not by itself establish compliance with the other. Whether a particular examiner must also supply a Rule 26 report is a question for the case.
What happens if the report is not delivered?
Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35(b)(5), the court on motion may order, on just terms, that a party deliver the report of an examination. If the report is not provided, the court may exclude the examiner’s testimony at trial. Both remedies are discretionary, and the rule does not make exclusion automatic.
The text reads: “The court on motion may order—on just terms—that a party deliver the report of an examination. If the report is not provided, the court may exclude the examiner’s testimony at trial.”
Before raising a missing-report issue with the court, counsel need a reviewable record. The following is an organizational workflow, not a statutory checklist:
- The request and delivery history, with dates.
- The examination order or the parties’ agreement.
- The specific report or component that is missing, for example an earlier same-condition report.
- Any case deadlines that bear on the examination or on expert disclosure.
Keeping these items together is a document-management task; the guide to organizing discovery documents covers the general approach.
How can Briefpoint support the related discovery workflow?
Briefpoint drafts responses and objections to interrogatories, requests for production and requests for admission, with output editable in Microsoft Word and attorneys keeping final review. Its Client Bridge sends clients plain-language questions through a secure link so they can answer and upload documents for attorney review. Autodoc finds responsive documents, adds page-level Bates citations and builds a Bates-numbered production package.
Those capabilities apply to the written discovery responses and document collection around an examination, such as collecting treatment records the client already has and uploads for attorney review. The product workflow discussed here is limited to related written discovery and client document collection, not the Rule 35 report request or the examiner’s medical findings. Counsel choose the procedural route, the privilege position, the scope and the documents to serve. Defense counsel who send or receive report requests can see discovery workflows for defense firms.
Book a demo to explore Briefpoint’s written-discovery workflow.
See Briefpoint in action:
What are the FAQs about a Rule 35 examiner report?
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35(b) governs who can request an examination report, what it must contain, the reciprocal exchange and the specified privilege waiver. The questions below separate the request-and-receipt trigger from the deposition trigger and explain why Rule 35(b) should not be given a generic 30-day deadline.
Can the person examined request the report if someone else is the party?
Yes. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35(b)(1) permits a request by the person examined as well as by the party against whom the order issued. Rule 35(a)(1) allows an order requiring a party to produce someone in its custody or under its legal control. The examined person and the party therefore need not be the same person.
Does asking for the report alone waive privilege under Rule 35(b)(4)?
Rule 35(b)(4) describes the report-based trigger as “requesting and obtaining” the report, not merely asking for it. Deposing the examiner is a separate trigger. The stated waiver concerns testimony about all examinations of the same condition in the action and other actions involving the same controversy; other privilege or waiver issues require separate analysis.
Does the moving party automatically receive earlier and later same-condition reports?
No. After delivering its reports, the moving party may request and is entitled to receive like reports of earlier or later examinations of the same condition from the party against whom the order issued, under Rule 35(b)(3). It does not say that every medical record is exchanged automatically at the examination. A party with custody or control of the person examined need not deliver those reports if it shows it could not obtain them.
Is the Rule 35 report due within 30 days?
Rule 35(b) itself contains no fixed 30-day report-delivery deadline. Rule 34(b)(2)(A) supplies a 30-day written-response period for Rule 34 requests, subject to its stated qualifications; that is not a universal Rule 35 deadline. Counsel assessing timing must distinguish the procedural route and any applicable examination agreement or case-specific order rather than import a generic discovery clock.
Does Rule 35(b) cover examinations agreed to without a court order?
Yes. Under Rule 35(b)(6), the report provisions also apply to an examination made by the parties’ agreement unless the agreement states otherwise. That default includes the report exchange and the specified waiver provision. The subsection also preserves the possibility of obtaining an examiner’s report or deposing the examiner under other rules; it does not promise that another route avoids every privilege consequence.
The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only. Information on this website may not constitute the most up-to-date legal or other information. This website contains links to other third-party websites. Such links are only for the convenience of the reader, user or browser. Readers of this website should contact their attorney to obtain advice with respect to any particular legal matter. No reader, user, or browser of this site should act or refrain from acting on the basis of information on this site without first seeking legal advice from counsel in the relevant jurisdiction. Only your individual attorney can provide assurances that the information contained herein – and your interpretation of it – is applicable or appropriate to your particular situation. Use of, and access to, this website or any of the links or resources contained within the site do not create an attorney-client relationship between the reader, user, or browser and website authors, contributors, contributing law firms, or committee members and their respective employers.