Notice to Admit New York: How Do You Respond?

Legal content overseen by Nathan Walter, Esq., attorney licensed in California (State Bar No. 313299).

In New York, a notice to admit is answered under CPLR 3123(a) with specific denials, detailed reasons why a matter cannot truthfully be admitted or denied, or the qualified statements the rule permits. The statute sets a base twenty-day response period after service, subject to further time allowed by the court and applicable service-method additions. Although CPLR 3123(a) calls for a sworn statement, current CPLR 2106(a) expressly permits a qualifying affirmation under penalties of perjury in its place.

This notice to admit New York guide explains response rules for defense teams, not case-specific due dates.

For general workflow, see our guide to the discovery response drafting workflow.

How do I respond to a notice to admit New York litigators serve?

A response to a New York notice to admit addresses the requested matters specifically rather than treating the notice as an ordinary letter. Under CPLR 3123(a), the responding party may specifically deny a matter, explain in detail why it cannot truthfully be admitted or denied, or provide the qualified statement the rule allows. CPLR 2106(a) supplies an affirmation alternative to the sworn form.

Two tasks run in parallel. The client or a witness supplies the facts about each requested matter, and an attorney decides how each matter is answered under the rule. The same attorney-reviewed approach applies to other written responses, as described in our overview of the discovery drafting process.

New York notice-to-admit essentials

The list below summarizes the rule:

• Scope: Documents, photographs, and facts that meet the no-substantial-dispute and knowledge-or-inquiry conditions. CPLR 3123(a).
• Base time: Twenty days after service, or further time the court allows. Service-method additions may apply. CPLR 3123(a); 2103(b)(2), (6).
• Response: Specific denial, a detailed statement of why the matter cannot be admitted or denied, or the permitted detailed qualification or claim. CPLR 3123(a).
• Execution: Sworn statement, or a qualifying affirmation under penalties of perjury. CPLR 3123(a); 2106(a).
• Silence: Properly requested matters are deemed admitted. CPLR 3123(a).
• Relief and costs: The court may allow amendment or withdrawal. A later-proved nonadmission can lead to expenses of proof. CPLR 3123(b)–(c).

What can a New York notice to admit ask me to admit?

CPLR 3123(a) permits requests concerning the genuineness of papers or documents, the correctness or fairness of representation of photographs, and the truth of matters of fact. The requesting party must reasonably believe there can be no substantial dispute at trial on the matter, and the matter must be within the other party’s knowledge or ascertainable on reasonable inquiry.

A notice to admit is a written request, served on another party, to admit those specific items so they need not be proved at trial. For the general concept, see our guide to requests for admission: purpose and examples.

Under CPLR 3123(a), the party serving the request must describe and serve with it the papers, documents, or photographs involved, and must serve copies unless copies have already been furnished.

The rule also sets a service window. A party may serve the request at any time after service of the answer or after twenty days from service of the summons, whichever is sooner, and not later than twenty days before trial.

Admitting a document’s genuineness is not the same as conceding it will be admitted at trial. Under CPLR 3123(b), any admission remains subject to all pertinent objections to admissibility that may be interposed at trial.

A defense-side example, invented for illustration: in a premises-liability case, the plaintiff serves a notice to admit attaching a photograph of a store aisle and asking the defendant to admit that the photograph fairly represents the aisle.

How many days do I have to respond to a notice to admit in New York?

CPLR 3123(a) provides a base twenty-day period after service, or further time the court may allow, for the specified response. CPLR 2103(b)(2) adds five days for mailing within New York or six days for mailing from outside New York but within the United States. CPLR 2103(b)(6) adds one business day for qualifying overnight delivery.

Twenty days is therefore not a universal calendar due date. Under CPLR 2103(b)(2), service by mail is complete upon mailing, and where a period is measured from service by mail, the five or six days are added to the prescribed period.

Under CPLR 2103(b)(6), service by overnight delivery service is complete upon deposit of the properly addressed wrapper with the overnight delivery service, before the latest time the service designates for overnight delivery. One business day is then added to the prescribed period.

Electronic service, weekend and holiday adjustments, tolling, stipulations, and judge-specific orders are outside this guide’s scope. Check each against the current rules and the case file.

What if I can only partly admit a statement or cannot admit or deny it?

Under CPLR 3123(a), a party that cannot truthfully admit or deny must set out the reasons in detail, rather than rely on a bare statement of uncertainty. If a matter cannot fairly be admitted without material qualification or explanation, the rule permits a detailed statement admitting it with that qualification or explanation.

CPLR 3123(a) describes these sworn-statement alternatives to an unqualified admission:

• A specific denial of the matters of which admission is requested.
• A statement setting forth in detail the reasons why the party cannot truthfully either admit or deny them.
• A statement setting forth in detail a claim that the matters cannot be fairly admitted without some material qualification or explanation, together with an admission of the matters with that qualification or explanation.
• A statement setting forth in detail a claim that the matters constitute a trade secret, or that the party would be privileged or disqualified from testifying as a witness concerning them.

Each of these is served as a sworn statement under CPLR 3123(a), subject to the affirmation alternative discussed below. Gathering the underlying facts and records first makes a detailed response possible. See our guide to organizing discovery documents and a discovery review checklist for pre-service review.

These two examples are invented to show response structure. They are not ready-to-serve forms, and they do not guarantee any legal result.

Does a New York notice to admit response have to be notarized?

A New York notice-to-admit response does not necessarily require notarization. CPLR 2106(a) expressly permits a person’s statement, subscribed and affirmed to be true under the penalties of perjury, to be used in lieu of and with the same force and effect as a response to a notice to admit.

That alternative does not make an ordinary unsworn letter sufficient. The affirmation must meet CPLR 2106(a)’s requirements.

CPLR 3123(a) still refers to a sworn statement. Read together with current CPLR 2106(a), the affirmation is an alternative form of that statement. Older summaries that omit the express notice-to-admit language in CPLR 2106(a) may be out of date, so confirm the current text.

CPLR 2106(a) states that the affirmation shall be in substantially the following form:

CPLR 2106(a) describes the statement of “any person,” subscribed and affirmed by that person. Who the proper signer is for a given response is a matter for the supervising attorney’s judgment.

What happens if I do not answer, and can I withdraw an admission?

For matters properly requested under CPLR 3123, subsection (a) provides that each matter is deemed admitted unless the specified response is served within the applicable response period: a base twenty days after service, with applicable service-method additions under CPLR 2103 and any further time the court may allow. Under subsection (b), an admission is for the pending action only, and the court may allow a party to amend or withdraw it on terms that are just.

A deemed admission is an automatic statutory consequence. Withdrawal is not automatic.

CPLR 3123(b) gives the court discretion to allow amendment or withdrawal “at any time,” on such terms as may be just. This guide states no test for how courts exercise that discretion, and serving a response late does not by itself cure a deemed admission.

CPLR 3123(b) also provides that an admission, made or deemed made, does not constitute an admission for any other purpose and may not be used against the party in any other proceeding. It remains subject to all pertinent objections to admissibility at trial.

A party that believes a request is improper should address that through the response options the rule provides and with attorney advice on the particular request.

Can refusing to admit a fact lead to attorney fees in New York?

Under CPLR 3123(c), a requesting party that later proves a matter the other party did not admit may move at or immediately following trial for the reasonable expenses of making that proof, including reasonable attorney’s fees. The order shall be made irrespective of the result of the action unless the court finds good reasons for the denial or refusal, or that the admissions sought were of no substantial importance.

This is not an immediate fee award for every denial. The requesting party must first prove the genuineness of the document, the correctness or fairness of the photograph, or the truth of the fact, and the recovery is limited to reasonable expenses incurred in making that proof. On a jury trial, CPLR 3123(c) provides that the court decides the motion outside the presence of the jury.

The two statutory exceptions, good reasons for the denial and admissions of no substantial importance, are why a response should record the specific basis for any denial.

How can Briefpoint help defense teams prepare discovery responses?

Briefpoint drafts responses and objections to interrogatories, requests for production, and requests for admission. Output is editable in Microsoft Word, and attorneys keep final review.

The software does not decide how a response should be framed under CPLR 3123 or 2106. Those judgments remain with the attorney.

Client Bridge sends clients plain-language questions through a secure link, so they can answer and upload documents for attorney review. For a defense team, that gives the attorney the client’s facts and documents to check against each requested matter. The platform also supports all 50 states and 98 federal courts, and more than 1,000 law firms use it. Its security is SOC 2 Type II and HIPAA-compliant.

For more, see the discovery drafting product, how AI discovery responses work, and solutions for defense firms.

To see how Briefpoint supports attorney-reviewed discovery drafting, Book a demo.

See how Briefpoint drafts discovery responses in minutes:

What are the FAQs about notice to admit New York procedure?

New York notice-to-admit procedure is governed by CPLR 3123. CPLR 2103 affects certain service-based periods, and CPLR 2106 governs the affirmation alternative.

How long do I have to respond to a notice to admit in New York?

CPLR 3123(a) sets a base period of twenty days after service, or such further time as the court may allow. Under CPLR 2103(b)(2), five days are added for service by mail within New York, or six from outside the state but within the United States. Under CPLR 2103(b)(6), one business day is added for qualifying overnight delivery. This guide does not supply a final due date.

Does a response to a New York notice to admit need to be notarized?

Not necessarily. CPLR 3123(a) refers to a sworn statement, but CPLR 2106(a) permits a statement subscribed and affirmed under penalties of perjury to be used in lieu of, and with the same force and effect as, a response to a notice to admit. An ordinary unsworn answer does not qualify. The affirmation must satisfy CPLR 2106(a).

Can I answer that I cannot admit or deny a statement?

Yes, if the response sets out in detail why you cannot truthfully do either. CPLR 3123(a) requires those reasons to be stated in detail. A qualified admission is different: where a matter cannot fairly be admitted without material qualification or explanation, the party serves a detailed statement admitting the matter with that qualification or explanation.

Can a deemed admission under CPLR 3123 be withdrawn?

The court may allow amendment or withdrawal on terms that are just. CPLR 3123(b) gives the court that authority at any time, but relief is not automatic. The statute also provides that an admission, made or deemed made, is for the purpose of the pending action only and remains subject to pertinent objections to admissibility at trial.

Can I owe attorney fees for denying a notice to admit?

Possibly. Under CPLR 3123(c), if a party does not admit and the requesting party later proves the matter, the requesting party may move at or immediately following trial for reasonable expenses of making that proof, including reasonable attorney’s fees. The order is made unless the court finds good reasons for the denial or that the admissions sought were of no substantial importance.

The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only. Information on this website may not constitute the most up-to-date legal or other information. This website contains links to other third-party websites. Such links are only for the convenience of the reader, user or browser. Readers of this website should contact their attorney to obtain advice with respect to any particular legal matter. No reader, user, or browser of this site should act or refrain from acting on the basis of information on this site without first seeking legal advice from counsel in the relevant jurisdiction. Only your individual attorney can provide assurances that the information contained herein – and your interpretation of it – is applicable or appropriate to your particular situation. Use of, and access to, this website or any of the links or resources contained within the site do not create an attorney-client relationship between the reader, user, or browser and website authors, contributors, contributing law firms, or committee members and their respective employers.